Customer exchanges: how to turn refunds into product exchanges

Customer exchanges: how to turn refunds into product exchanges

How to offer customer exchanges shoppers pick over a refund: size swaps, Exchange for Anything, bonus credit, discount codes, in-store and instant exchanges.

Key takeaways

  • A product exchange keeps the sale when a customer returns something. Your returns flow decides whether they leave with a refund, an exchange or store credit.
  • Shoppers pick an exchange when it's easy and costs them nothing extra: quick size swaps, Exchange for Anything (also known as Shop Now), bonus credit, their own discount codes and free shipping on the new item.
  • With Refundid's instant exchanges the replacement ships straight away, and Refundid carries the risk if the original item never comes back.

A refund is the only return outcome where the money leaves your business. An exchange keeps the sale, and store credit keeps the value in your store for the next order. Most retailers would rather see either one, and plenty of shoppers would too, as long as it's easy.

The trouble is that shoppers pick the easiest option in front of them, and on a lot of returns portals that's the refund. Below is what a good customer exchange experience should offer, in the order a shopper meets it while lodging a return, with Refundid as the example.

What is a product exchange?

A product exchange is when a customer sends back an item and gets a different one instead of their money. It might be the same product in another size or colour, or something else from your store. With a return, the customer gets a refund and the sale is gone. With an exchange, the sale stays with you.

Start with an easy online exchange

Nobody wants to swap a product over email. An online returns portal where shoppers organise the exchange themselves is the starting point for everything below.

The most common exchange is a variant exchange: the same product in a different size or colour. It has the fewest steps because the shopper only picks from that product's variants. If the item was bought on sale and is back at full price, Refundid can match the price they originally paid so they aren't charged the difference.

Refundid can also suggest the right variant for them. Based on the item, the return reason and the shopper's answers, it preselects a likely fit with a short explanation, for example one size up when the reason is "too small". The shopper can take the suggestion or choose something else.

Refundid suggesting one size up after a too small return reason
A "too small" return gets a one size up suggestion. The shopper can still pick any variant.

If you're on Shopify and want to know what it handles without an app, read our guide to handling exchanges on Shopify.

Let shoppers swap for any product with Exchange for Anything

A different size doesn't help when the shopper simply doesn't like the product. Exchange for Anything, also known as Shop Now, lets them spend the value of their return on anything in your store instead.

There are two ways to run it. In the returns portal, shoppers browse the collections you choose and pick a new item without leaving the return. On your own store, they're sent back to your website with their credit balance showing at the bottom of the page, so they shop with your normal navigation and merchandising, then come back to finish the return.

Exchange for Anything (Shop Now) in the Refundid returns portal
Exchange for Anything in the returns portal: the shopper swaps a shirt for a dress using their return credit.

If they choose something that costs more, they pay the difference by card in the portal. That's extra revenue on a return, and it's paid to you once the return is approved.

Keep leftover value in your store

If they choose something cheaper, there's value left over. Sending all of it back as a refund lets money leave your business on a return that was meant to keep the sale. A good exchange flow lets you decide where that difference goes.

In Refundid, the leftover amount can go back to the shopper as a refund, as store credit or as a gift card. Refunding is the default, and you can switch to store credit or a gift card in your exchange settings. The shopper is told where the difference will go before they finish the return, and it's paid out once the return is approved.

Make credit the better deal with bonus credit

Bonus credit adds extra value when a shopper picks store credit or an Exchange for Anything instead of a refund. With a 10% bonus, a shopper returning $100 of items gets $110 to spend. The portal shows it on the option itself, for example "Exchange + Bonus 10%", and the shopper sees the bonus included in their available credit while they shop.

Return method options showing store credit and exchange with a 10% bonus
Bonus Credit shows on the options themselves, next to a plain refund.

You choose a fixed amount or a percentage. Bonus credit can only be spent, never cashed out, so a shopper who takes it is staying with your store.

Exchange cart showing bonus credit covering the price difference
Here the bonus covers the extra $10, so the shopper pays nothing more.

You don't have to give everyone the same bonus. With Flows you can set a bigger bonus for VIP customers, a different one for certain products or return reasons, or none at all for frequent returners.

Let shoppers use a discount code on an exchange

A shopper with a discount code from your newsletter or a promotion will want to use it on their new item, especially when it costs more than what they're sending back. If the code only works on a fresh order, a refund followed by a new purchase can look like the better deal.

On Shopify stores, Refundid can show a discount code field when the shopper confirms their exchange. The code is checked as soon as they enter it, and the summary lists the items, bonus credit, discount and shipping on separate lines so they can see exactly what they'll pay.

It's off by default. You turn it on separately for size and colour swaps and for Exchange for Anything, so you can allow codes only where the shopper is choosing a new product if you prefer.

Use your return rules to steer the choice

Your return rules decide which options a shopper sees and what each one costs them. A few that make exchanges and credit the obvious pick:

  • Free return shipping for exchanges and store credit, with a return shipping fee on refunds.
  • Preselecting the exchange or store credit option so it's the default.
  • Hiding the refund option for change-of-mind returns on final sale items or for specific customers.

Rules like these apply to change-of-mind returns. In Australia, a faulty item still has to be refunded, repaired or replaced under consumer law, so check your policy against our guide to change of mind refund laws in Australia.

Take the cost out of exchanging

Small costs push shoppers back towards a refund. Remove them where you can:

  • Offer free shipping on the replacement order.
  • Waive duties on international exchange orders so overseas shoppers don't pay twice.
  • Match the original price when a sale item is back at full price.
  • Let shoppers exchange some items and refund others in the same return, instead of turning the whole return into a refund.

Offer store credit when they don't want a swap

Some shoppers don't want anything today but will buy again. Store credit, as a gift card or credit on their customer account, keeps that value in your store. Add bonus credit and it becomes a better deal than the refund. If you sell in Australia, read our guide to refund timeframes and store credit before you set an expiry.

Handle in-store exchanges the same way

Not every customer exchange starts online. When a customer brings an item back to one of your stores, your staff should be able to offer the same exchange they'd get on your website, even when the store doesn't have their size.

In Refundid, staff lodge the return for the customer and pick the replacement, and the stock shown follows the location the new item will be sent from. If the customer wants it delivered somewhere other than the address on the original order, such as their work, staff untick "Ship to original address" and search for the new address or enter it by hand. The exchange shipping price updates to match, and the return shows where the new item is going.

Provide instant exchanges with Refundid

The fastest exchange is one where the shopper doesn't wait for their return to arrive first. With instant exchanges, the replacement is ordered as soon as the return is lodged.

instant exchanges with Refundid

How it works

The shopper enters their order details, selects the items they're returning and chooses the replacement. Refundid places and pays for the new order through your checkout, and you ship it like any other order.

Show shoppers the order going through

Placing an instant exchange takes a few moments, and a small spinner on a button leaves shoppers unsure whether it worked. Some tap again, and some close the page. Refundid is rolling out a full-screen progress screen for that wait: the new items drop into a shopping bag with their real photos and sizes, and it finishes with an "Ordered" label and the new order number.

Finance-friendly exchanges

Your finance team doesn't need to change anything. Exchange orders flow through your store and on to your other systems like any other order, and you don't need to hold stock aside before the return arrives.

Zero risk for retailers

Refundid takes on the risk. If the shopper never sends the original item back, you still keep the sale. There are no fees unless the return is approved, and nothing changes on the original order unless it is.

Clear emails if an exchange is cancelled

Sometimes a return is cancelled after the instant exchange order has been placed. The shopper keeps their original item, so the return credit that paid for the new order has to be paid back. Refundid's cancellation email explains this in plain terms: how much of the credit paid for which exchange order, any fees on top, and the total that will be taken from their nominated account. The shopper isn't left guessing what the charge is for.

Tell shoppers what you offer

None of this helps if shoppers don't know about it. Put your exchange options in your returns policy and on your product pages:

  • Say plainly that shoppers can swap sizes or pick something else, and mention any bonus credit.
  • Say whether discount codes work on exchanges and where any leftover value goes.
  • List any costs, exceptions and your exchange window.
  • Keep your exchange policy consistent with the rest of your returns policy.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between a return and an exchange?

With a return, the customer sends the item back and gets a refund, so the sale is lost. With an exchange, they send it back and get a different item, so the sale stays with your store. Store credit sits in between: the value stays with you until they spend it.

What is Exchange for Anything (Shop Now)?

Exchange for Anything, also known as Shop Now, lets a shopper exchange a returned item for any product in your store, not only a different size or colour of the same item. With Refundid they can shop inside the returns portal or on your own website using the value of their return.

What is bonus credit?

Bonus credit is extra value a shopper gets for choosing an exchange or store credit instead of a refund, for example 10% on top of the return value. It can be spent but not refunded.

Can I offer bonus credit only to some customers?

Yes. Using Flows in Refundid you can change the bonus, or remove it, based on things like customer tags, VIP tier, products or the return reason.

What happens if the new item costs more or less?

If it costs more, the shopper pays the difference by card in the returns portal. If they pick a cheaper product, the difference goes back to them as a refund, store credit or a gift card, depending on your settings, once the return is approved.

Can customers use a discount code on an exchange?

With Refundid on Shopify, yes, if you turn it on. It's off by default, and you can allow codes on size and colour swaps, on Exchange for Anything, or both.

Can an exchange be shipped to a different address?

Yes. Shoppers can choose a different delivery address when they lodge an exchange online, and your staff can do the same when they lodge an exchange in store.

Is it included in Refundid's pricing?

Exchanges, Exchange for Anything and bonus credit are included in the Core plan. Instant exchanges are priced separately. See pricing for details.

See every exchange and store credit feature in one place on our exchanges and store credit page, or book a demo to see how Refundid can turn more of your returns into exchanges.

Insights

You might also like

Singapore's Lemon Law: repair, replace or refund, what online stores must do

Singapore Lemon Law: a guide for online retailers

What Singapore's Lemon Law means for online stores and return policies...

Reverse logistics in ecommerce: a return moving from lodged to back in stock

What is reverse logistics in ecommerce? Stages and where returns end up

How returns move back through a store and where they end up...